Free 2-Day Shipping + Extended Holiday Returns. Learn More.

Gemstone Engagement Rings - Beyond Diamonds: Why Today’s Couples Choose Gemstone Rings

gemstone engagement ring, gemstone jewelry, gemstones, lab gemstones
11/11/2024
Gemstone Engagement Rings - Beyond Diamonds: Why Today’s Couples Choose Gemstone Rings

In recent years, a colorful revolution has been taking place in the world of engagement rings. While diamonds have long held court as the traditional choice, many couples are increasingly drawn to the vibrant allure of rings featuring precious and semi-precious gems. Let’s explore this recent trend and take a look at some of our favorite gemstone engagement rings from John Atencio’s celebrated jewelry collection.

The Appeal of Gemstone Rings

In recent years, sapphires, rubies, emeralds, and aquamarines have emerged as popular diamond ring alternatives, offering couples the opportunity to express their unique love stories through distinctive, personalized pieces. This shift represents more than just a departure from tradition; it's a reflection of how today’s couples view their relationships and themselves. 

 

woman showing off her gemstone engagement ring

 

The rising popularity of gemstone engagement rings speaks to a desire for individuality, meaning, and personal expression in every aspect of the marriage journey, starting with the symbol of commitment itself. The appeal of gemstone engagement rings lies in their remarkable diversity and rich symbolic significance. Each gemstone brings unique character and meaning to the table, offering couples a spectrum of choices that go beyond the traditional diamond. 

Popular Gemstone Options

When it comes to alternative engagement rings, certain gemstones tend to attract the most interest due to their combination of meaning and beauty. 

Sapphire engagement rings, with their deep blue or, as in the example above, pink hues, have long symbolized loyalty and wisdom. This connection to royalty and romance was notably highlighted when Prince William proposed to Kate Middleton with his mother's sapphire ring, sparking a renewed interest in colored gemstone engagement rings worldwide.

Known as the "king of precious stones," rubies represent passion and prosperity. Their rich red color has made them symbols of love and commitment across cultures for centuries. In many ancient societies, the gorgeous red gems were believed to hold the power of life itself, making them particularly significant for marking life's most important moments. 

a display of gemstone engagement rings including emerald

 

Emerald and aquamarine rings have also become popular in recent years. Emeralds, with their lush green tones, embody growth, harmony, and new beginnings—fitting symbols for couples starting their lives together. These verdant gems have been prized since ancient times, and Cleopatra herself was known for coveting them. 

With their serene blue hues, aquamarines represent tranquility and clear communication, essential elements for any lasting relationship. Their connection to the ocean and its calming properties makes them especially meaningful for couples who find peace and inspiration in the Earth’s natural beauty.

Comparative Advantage

When considering gemstones versus diamonds, it's important to understand both their physical properties and practical implications. On the Mohs scale of hardness, diamonds lead at 10, while sapphires and rubies (both varieties of corundum) rank at 9. 

Emeralds measure between 7.5 and 8, and aquamarines register from 7.5 to 8. While these gemstones may be slightly less durable than diamonds, they still offer excellent hardness for everyday wear when properly set and maintained. Understanding these characteristics helps inform both design choices and care requirements for long-term wear.

In most cases, gems are less expensive than diamonds, allowing couples to obtain larger, more impressive stones for their budget. This value proposition doesn't compromise quality or beauty—many gemstones offer exceptional clarity and brilliance, with unique optical properties that can make them more captivating than diamonds in certain lights. 

Gemstones also often exhibit fascinating phenomena such as color change, asterism (star effect), or chatoyancy (cat's eye effect), adding another dimension of interest and uniqueness to engagement rings. When considering investment value, many rare gemstones have appreciated significantly over time, particularly fine rubies and sapphires from historic sources.

Why Today’s Couples Choose Gemstones

Today's couples are increasingly drawn to gemstone engagement rings for several compelling reasons. First and foremost is the desire for uniqueness. In a world where authenticity is highly valued, a carefully chosen gemstone can make a powerful personal statement. 

a blue sapphire engagement ring

 

The storytelling aspect of gemstone rings also resonates with today’s couples. Whether it's choosing a birthstone, a color that holds special meaning, or a gem that represents shared values, these personal touches create a deeper connection to the ring itself. 

This personalization extends beyond the stone choice to the entire design process, allowing couples to create truly one-of-a-kind pieces that reflect their relationship. Many couples appreciate how a colored gemstone can become a conversation starter, allowing them to share their unique love story through the symbolism of their chosen stone.

Styling and Pairing with Gemstone Rings

Styling a gemstone engagement ring requires thoughtful consideration of both aesthetics and practicality. When selecting a gemstone ring for daily wear, consider how the color complements your existing jewelry and wardrobe. Some couples opt for mixing gemstones in their settings, creating stunning combinations that tell their unique story through color and symbolism. 

The possibilities for creative expression are virtually endless, from classic solitaire designs that let the gemstone take center stage to more elaborate settings that incorporate multiple stones and intricate metalwork. For wedding bands, consider complementary metals and designs that enhance rather than compete with the engagement ring. White metals like platinum or white gold can create a sophisticated backdrop for colored stones, while rose gold rings can add warmth and romance to cooler-toned gems. 

Many couples are also exploring innovative approaches to wedding sets, such as nested bands that embrace the center stone or graduated gemstone bands that create an ombré effect when worn together. The key is to create a cohesive look that allows each piece to shine while working together harmoniously.

John Atencio and Gemstone Engagement Rings

At John Atencio, the process of creating a gemstone engagement ring is an artistic journey guided by decades of expertise. Each customized ring begins with a careful consultation to understand the couple's vision, style preferences, and lifestyle considerations. 

Through relationships with premier stone dealers worldwide, John can source the perfect gemstone to bring that vision to life. His commitment to high quality extends beyond the stones themselves to every aspect of the design and creation process, ensuring that each ring meets his exacting standards for both beauty and durability.

John’s signature designs showcase gemstones in settings that enhance their natural beauty while ensuring durability for everyday wear. For example, his emerald rings often feature protective bezels or special settings that guard against chips, while our sapphire designs might emphasize the stone's remarkable color through strategic metal choices and accent stones. 

Each design is carefully considered to protect the gemstone while maximizing its natural beauty and ensuring comfort for daily wear.

Choosing a Gemstone Ring

For couples considering a gemstone engagement ring, John Atencio recommends these key considerations:

  • Consider your lifestyle and daily activities when selecting both stone and setting.
  • Think about the meaning and symbolism you want your ring to convey.
  • Understand the care requirements for your chosen gemstone.
  • Explore different metal options that complement your stone's color.
  • Don't be afraid to mix traditional and contemporary elements in your design.
  • Consider how your ring will pair with future jewelry pieces.
  • Take time to learn about your chosen gemstone's unique characteristics.

 

If you’re not sure where to start, meet with one of John’s attentive consultants, who will work with you to choose the perfect gemstone that reflects your one-of-a-kind love story.

Embracing Alternative Engagement Ring Designs

The rise of gemstone engagement rings represents a beautiful evolution in how couples symbolize their commitment. These rings offer not just an alternative to traditional diamonds, but an opportunity to create something deeply personal and meaningful. 

Whether it's a classic blue sapphire, a passionate ruby, a verdant emerald, or a serene aquamarine, each gemstone ring tells a unique story—your story. 

When you're ready to explore the possibilities of a gemstone engagement ring, John Atencio's expert designers and craftsmen are here to guide you through every step of the process, from stone selection to final design. Shop online or visit one of his many nearby locations in Denver, Boulder, Fort Collins or shopping malls to choose a beautiful symbol of your love and a lasting heirloom to be treasured for generations to come.