Craft Your Unique Love Story with a Custom Engagement Ring by John Atencio

At John Atencio, we believe every love story deserves a ring as unique as the bond it represents. With over 49 years of craftsmanship and design expertise, we offer a bespoke experience that allows you to create a custom engagement ring tailored to your personal style and vision. Whether you’re drawn to a Modern, Halo, Three-Stone, or Solitaire design—or something entirely your own—our team is here to guide you through every step of the process. We ensure your engagement ring becomes a true reflection of your love and commitment, combining bold architecture and timeless artistry to create a piece designed to last a lifetime.

Recent John Atencio Custom Rings

The Custom Design Process at John Atencio

Our custom engagement ring journey is a seamless and personalized experience. It begins with an initial consultation where we listen to your ideas, preferences, and inspiration. From there, our designers work together with you to sketch and refine the perfect design, considering your choice of precious metals, diamond or gemstone preferences, and any unique details that hold special meaning. Once your design is finalized, our artisans meticulously craft your ring, ensuring every detail is perfected to the highest standard. The result is a one-of-a-kind piece that not only tells your story but is also built to last a lifetime. Learn more from our blog: Why John Atencio is Denver's Destination for Bespoke Engagement Rings.

At John Atencio, we have 48 years of expertise in design. This expertise extends to working with customers to design a ring that will meet John Atencio's strict standards for quality and last a lifetime. Through every step of the design process, we work collaboratively with our customers to make sure the ring is perfect.

Whether you want a ring with a fancy shaped stone, a nontraditional setting or a contemporary creation that combines more than one style, John Atencio can craft a distinctively beautiful custom engagement ring that's as unique as your love story.

We invite you to explore our stunning John Atencio engagement ring designs. You can easily Shop by Style or Shop by Collection below to find the perfect ring that reflects your unique love story.

Make An Appointment

Shop By Collection

View All Diamond Rings

Elite Colletion

New Bridal Rings

Fancy Collection

Shop By Style

Solitaire

Halo

Three-Stone

Modern

At John Atencio, we are committed to offering only the highest quality diamonds, each hand-selected for its brilliance, ethical sourcing, and certification by respected authorities such as GIA. Whether you're considering a lab-grown or natural diamond, we encourage you to explore our certified diamonds online. This allows you to review our selection before visiting one of our stores, where our experts can guide you in finding the perfect diamond for your custom engagement ring and budget. (Explore our recent blog: Lab vs. Natural Diamonds: Understanding Your Choices)

Shop By Diamond

SEARCH OUR NATURAL DIAMONDS

SEARCH OUR LAB-GROWN DIAMONDS

With nearly five decades of design expertise, John Atencio is celebrated for creating engagement rings that combine timeless artistry with unparalleled quality. Our custom rings take this to the next level, offering a one-of-a-kind expression of your love. Crafted using only the finest gems and precious metals, every ring meets John's exacting standards for excellence. Whether your vision includes a distinctive stone, an unconventional setting, or a bold contemporary design, we are committed to delivering a ring that not only captures your story but is built to last a lifetime.

Testimonials

I proposed to my Wife on Christmas Day with the most beautifully, custom-made ring either of us could have imagined. The care and attention to detail they put into designing our dream rings really captured the essence of what was in my mind for my Queen. Our rings match perfectly and scream “Royalty”; absolute statement pieces. We’re complimented on our rings anytime we leave the house. John Atencio and his team are friendly, skilled, professional and an absolute pleasure to work with.

Fun fact: I’m from out of town and working with them via telephone/email was just as seamless as me being there in person!

— J. Worrell

…After we approved the digital sketch, we were told it would take 4-6 weeks for the rings to be ready but they were ready ahead of schedule! The quality of our jewelry is unmatched. I absolutely love our rings and have a hard time believing any other jeweler would have taken the time that John Atencio and his team took to ensure that they surpassed our expectations.

— A.Worrell