Custom Engagement Rings

John Atencio diamond ring settings can be customized for any diamond size or metal. You can shop by first by diamond or by setting.

Shop By Diamond

SEARCH OUR NATURAL DIAMONDS

SEARCH OUR LAB-GROWN DIAMONDS

Shop By Setting

Modern

Classic

Pavé

Solitaire

Recent John Atencio Custom Rings

Make An Appointment

John Atencio is renowned for fashioning exceptional engagement rings using only the finest gems and precious metals. While all of his pieces reflect the artistry of a master craftsman, John's custom rings take things further by providing a personalized expression of your commitment and love.

At John Atencio, we have 48 years of expertise in design. This expertise extends to working with customers to design a ring that will meet John Atencio's strict standards for quality and last a lifetime. Through every step of the design process, we work collaboratively with our customers to make sure the ring is perfect.

Whether you want a ring with a fancy shaped stone, a nontraditional setting or a contemporary creation that combines more than one style, John Atencio can craft a distinctively beautiful custom engagement ring that's as unique as your love story.

Testimonials

I proposed to my Wife on Christmas Day with the most beautifully, custom-made ring either of us could have imagined. The care and attention to detail they put into designing our dream rings really captured the essence of what was in my mind for my Queen. Our rings match perfectly and scream “Royalty”; absolute statement pieces. We’re complimented on our rings anytime we leave the house. John Atencio and his team are friendly, skilled, professional and an absolute pleasure to work with.

Fun fact: I’m from out of town and working with them via telephone/email was just as seamless as me being there in person!

— J. Worrell

…After we approved the digital sketch, we were told it would take 4-6 weeks for the rings to be ready but they were ready ahead of schedule! The quality of our jewelry is unmatched. I absolutely love our rings and have a hard time believing any other jeweler would have taken the time that John Atencio and his team took to ensure that they surpassed our expectations.

— A.Worrell