Unique Engagement Ring Shapes: The Fancies Are Back

As couples seek to express their unique personalities and relationships, fancy-cut diamonds are experiencing a powerful resurgence. Let’s explore the increasing popularity of fancy-cut diamonds and take a look at some of our favorites from John Atencio’s famous collection.
Unique Engagement Ring Shapes
While the classic round brilliant cut has dominated engagement ring preferences for decades, today's couples are drawn to the distinctive character and personal statement offered by alternative diamond shapes. These "fancy" cuts create opportunities for self-expression while maintaining the timeless symbolism of the diamond engagement ring.
"Fancy cut" refers to any diamond shape other than the traditional round brilliant. While round brilliants are cut to maximize light performance through standardized proportions, fancy cuts offer varied silhouettes that present different visual effects and personality traits.
These alternative shapes aren't new inventions—many have fascinating historical roots. Cushion cuts dominated the Victorian era, while Art Deco popularized emerald and Asscher cuts. Marquise diamonds trace their lineage to King Louis XV, who commissioned a diamond shaped like his mistress's smile. Today's resurgence of these shapes represents both innovation and homage to jewelry's rich heritage, which spans millennia.

Popular Engagement Ring Styles
The variety of fancy cuts provides options to suit every personality and aesthetic preference. Some of the most popular shapes include:
Pear diamonds: These combine the brilliance of a round with the distinctive point of a marquise, creating an elegant teardrop that elongates the finger and offers graceful proportions.
Oval diamonds: These present a modern twist on classic brilliance. Their elongated shape creates the illusion of greater size while providing versatility for various settings and hand types.
Marquise diamonds: This shape features dramatic pointed ends that maximize carat weight appearance. They make a confident statement while creating a lengthening effect on the finger.
Cushion diamonds: These beautiful shapes balance vintage charm and contemporary appeal with their rounded corners and larger facets. Their soft, pillow-like appearance offers exceptional versatility and romantic character.
Emerald diamonds: These fancy cuts showcase sophistication through their rectangular shape and step-cut faceting. Rather than maximizing sparkle, they highlight clarity and color while providing sleek, understated elegance.

Trending Engagement Rings for 2025
Today's couples approach engagement rings as personal artifacts that should reflect their unique bond rather than conform to tradition. This has fueled interest in custom designs that incorporate distinctive center stones as focal points for truly individual creations.
We're also witnessing a significant vintage revival influencing contemporary ring design. Shapes like marquise and emerald cuts evoke different historical eras while feeling thoroughly modern in updated settings. This intersection of nostalgic reference and current sensibility creates pieces with emotional and aesthetic depth.
Nature-inspired and organic designs have also gained particular momentum, incorporating various fancy shapes in combination. Asymmetrical arrangements featuring multiple smaller fancy-cut diamonds create flowing compositions that celebrate natural beauty and irregularity.
While celebrity engagement rings certainly influence trends, today's fancy cut renaissance extends beyond famous fingers. The broader movement toward bespoke creations and rejection of cookie-cutter designs has empowered couples to explore options beyond traditional choices, considering their personal style rather than following conventional expectations.
Choosing the Perfect Fancy Shape for Your Style
Selecting the ideal fancy shape involves considering several personal factors. For instance, longer fingers often complement bold shapes like marquise or pear, while shorter fingers may be better served by shapes with more balanced proportions. The width of your finger also matters—narrow fingers can be overwhelmed by very wide cuts, while broader fingers can beautifully showcase substantial shapes.
You should also consider how certain shapes create optical illusions on the hand. Elongated shapes like oval, pear, and marquise visually lengthen fingers, while shapes with greater width like radiant or Asscher may appear to shorten them. These effects should factor into your decision based on your hand's natural proportions.
Your personal aesthetic should ultimately guide your choice. Those drawn to vintage styles might gravitate toward cushion or Asscher cuts with their historical references. Minimalist tastes often find harmony with emerald or baguette cuts. Romantic personalities, on the other hand, might connect with the flowing lines of pear or oval shapes.
Lifestyle considerations also matter. Active individuals should consider shapes without sharp points that might snag or settings that provide adequate protection. Certain professions or hobbies might also influence the height or security of your setting.
John Atencio's personalized consultation process can help you navigate these considerations. His experts can guide you through different options, trying various shapes and settings, to help find a combination that resonates most deeply with your vision and lifestyle. He also has a sample kit in each of his stores featuring all the popular diamond shapes to help customers determine which looks best on their hands.
The John Atencio Difference
John Atencio’s engagement rings reflect the legendary artist’s unwavering commitment to quality. Each design showcases decades of expertise in selecting exceptional diamonds and crafting settings that enhance their natural beauty. This unrelenting dedication ensures that every ring meets the highest standards of excellence.
John’s commitment to perfection extends to ethical sourcing, using only responsibly sourced metals and conflict-free diamonds. This ensures that the beauty of your engagement ring isn't compromised by concerns about its origins or environmental impact.
The creation process involves meticulous setting techniques that secure each diamond while maximizing its light performance. Master craftspeople hand-finish every detail, creating rings that are as structurally sound as they are visually stunning. This attention to craftsmanship guarantees that every diamond is properly supported and protected within its setting.
For those seeking something truly unique, John Atencio offers comprehensive customization options. The process begins with understanding your vision and preferences. John’s team then works with you to explore possibilities for modifying existing designs or creating entirely bespoke pieces. This collaborative approach ensures that your ring authentically reflects your relationship's unique character, so you get a ring that’s truly one of a kind.
Experience the difference that exceptional design makes by exploring John Atencio's collection online or by visiting a store to discover possibilities in person. Whether you're drawn to the romantic curves of a pear, the sophisticated lines of an emerald, or another fancy shape entirely, John Atencio's expertise will help you find or create the perfect expression of your love story.