Our First Valentine’s Day! The Top Valentine’s Day Jewelry Gift Ideas
Last Updated January 2026
Have you been thinking about Valentine’s jewelry gift ideas for your special someone for your first official Valentine’s day together? Romance has been in the air since you met and you want to show her that she means the world to you, so it’s wise to seriously consider the perfect present for the day of hearts. Whether you’re celebrating your first Valentine’s Day after popping the question or you’ve recently met and you’re on cloud nine, this day is one you’ll always both remember. This special day will only happen once, so make it memorable by presenting the one you love with a jewelry gift they’ll always cherish. Show them just how much you treasure them by gifting them with distinctive jewelry from John Atencio.
Celebrate Love with John Atencio
A master jewelry designer with over 50 years of experience, John Atencio is known the world over for his cleanly bold designs that speak the language of love. Crafting distinctive statement jewelry that conveys the devotion between two people is essential to this master jeweler, because love is the reason he initiated a lifetime career in jewelry design. Every piece begins as a personal hand-sketch of his vision, becoming a remarkable reality by the hands of master artisans who use the highest standards in craftsmanship and attention to detail to craft these heirlooms. This, plus his insistence on using responsibly sourced gemstones and employing fair mining practices, make John Atencio jewelry the wearable art your love will be overjoyed to receive.
It’s All About Hearts
Used across the globe to symbolize the emotions of love and affection, the shape of a heart is thought to have been derived by scientists and artists illustrating ancient medical texts in the Middle Ages. This universal symbol transferred to romantic love over the ages, coming to represent Valentine’s Day in beautiful fashion. Giving your sweetheart heart-shaped jewelry on this day of love is now a widespread tradition, and John Atencio has made it simple to do with his extensive collection of Valentine jewelry gifts. Presenting dozens of distinctive heart-shaped pieces, including pendants and earrings, John Atencio offers the perfect first Valentine’s Day jewelry gift that will make your love smile every time they wear it or use it.
Say it in Red and Pink
John Atencio offers stylish statement jewelry in the delightful hues of red and pink that have come to embody modern Valentine’s Day. Vibrant gemstone color brings warmth and emotion to every design, making it a natural choice when selecting a meaningful Valentine’s gift. Pieces like the Antigua Birthstone Stack Ring, Antigua Birthstone Stacking Bangle Bracelet, and Antigua Birthstone Stud Earrings allow her to celebrate color in a way that feels personal and easy to wear every day.
For a bolder expression, gemstone designs from the Arrivo and Venture collections offer refined brilliance through rich stones like rhodolite garnet and amethyst. From the Arrivo Trillion Solitaire Pendant Necklace and Arrivo Petite Trillion Cuff Bracelet to gemstone-forward Venture bracelets, rings, earrings, and pendants accented with diamonds, these designs balance color with craftsmanship. Heart-shaped favorites such as the Endearment Gemstone Heart Pendant Necklace add a romantic finish, proving that a little red or pink goes a long way when it’s designed to last.
Favorite Valentine’s Gifts
When you’re mulling over which Valentine’s jewelry gifts to give, it’s easy to turn to John Atencio’s favorites because some designs never lose their impact. If bold gold speaks to her style, the Havana Hoops or the Havana Wide Ring deliver effortless confidence through sleek 14-karat gold silhouettes inspired by the vibrant energy of Havana. Each piece feels modern, polished, and unmistakably distinctive.
For a more luminous statement, look to the Bellagio Pendant Necklace or Bellagio Earrings, where continuous woven channel-set diamonds flow across high-polish gold finishes. Inspired by movement and light, these refined designs bring radiant brilliance that feels unforgettable. Any of these signature favorites are sure to leave a lasting impression and make this Valentine’s Day one she’ll always remember.
Selecting her gift for your first Valentine’s Day together is easy because John Atencio has an abundance of stunning Valentine jewelry gift ideas. Browse the Valentine’s Gift Guide. When you're ready, you can make an appointment with a concierge on the site or come to the store in Larimer Square in Downtown Denver, Cherry Creek, Boulder, Fort Collins, Park Meadows or Flatiron Crossing for an in-person browsing experience. Because love always comes first at John Atencio.
Browse John Atencio's 2026 Valentine Look Book
Discover this season’s curated gift guide for the latest collections and a full range of Valentine’s favorites. the Shop the 2026 Valentine gift guide.
