Free Overnight Shipping, Extended Returns + A Gift with Purchase for orders by 12/21 at 1PM MST.

Fort Collins Engagement Rings

Each John Atencio engagement ring is an artistic expression of your unique love story, custom-crafted with meticulous detail to reflect your journey and commitment. In today’s world of engagement rings, John Atencio redefines tradition with striking designs, bold architecture, and a 49-year legacy of excellence. Each ring is custom-crafted to include your choice of a lab or natural certified diamond or gemstone, hand-selected for its quality and ethical sourcing. With a variety of styles—Modern, Halo, Three-Stone, and Solitaire—and stunning fancy cuts like Oval, Pear, Emerald, and Radiant, our rings are designed to endure life’s—and Colorado’s—adventures. Discover the legacy of John Atencio by visiting our Fort Collins location, where our experts will help you explore our extensive selection of engagement rings and diamonds to perfectly reflect your love and your budget.
Shop By Style
Shop By Collection
John Atencio Fort Collins Store

John Atencio - Fort Collins

John Atencio's first store opened in 1976 in Fort Collins, near the Colorado State University campus where John is an honored alumnus. His store on North College Avenue is a homecoming from where it all began. The Fort Collins location is one of John's premier boutiques, where people come from far and wide to see, touch and feel each unique design in celebration of their life events. Weddings, births, anniversaries and more are each celebrated through John's engagement rings, women's wedding rings, men's wedding bands, anniversary rings, and collection bracelets, pendants & necklaces and earrings.

Now is the time to browse our Fort Collins Engagement rings, select the ideal gemstone for your budget, and work with you to coordinate the crafting of your ring.

Make an Appointment

Tues – Sat: 11am – 5pm

Sunday & Monday: closed

See What Our Customers Are Saying