Free Overnight Shipping, Extended Returns + A Gift with Purchase for orders by 12/21 at 1PM MST.

Diamond Studs – How to Choose the Best Carat Weight for You

1 carat diamond studs, 2 carat diamond studs, diamond earrings, diamond stud earrings, diamond studs, lab created diamonds
9/9/2024
Diamond Studs – How to Choose the Best Carat Weight for You

Nothing elevates your look like a pair of scintillating diamond stud earrings. Endlessly versatile, these wardrobe staples go with anything, especially when you choose the right carat weight. But is carat weight really all that important? Let’s compare 1- vs. 2-carat diamond stud earrings to better understand the benefits and potential limitations of larger carat weights.

Carat Weight

Diamond stud earrings have long been cherished as timeless accessories, offering elegance and sophistication. Their versatility makes them suitable for both everyday wear and formal events, enhancing any look with a touch of class. However, selecting the perfect carat weight is essential in determining both the aesthetic and value of the earrings.

The allure of these studs lies not just in their beauty but also in choosing a size that complements your style and enhances the brilliance of the diamonds themselves. This starts with understanding the basics of carat weight.

While many believe that “carat” refers to the size of a diamond, the term is actually one of weight measurement. That said, carat does have a significant impact on the actual size of a diamond gemstone. In general, the more a diamond weighs, the larger it tends to be.

Carat Total Weight (CTW)

When shopping for a diamond, it’s important to understand certain terminology which gives insight into the actual stone. One important term is CTW, which stands for carat total weight.

Most diamond studs will be labeled with a CTW value. If you don’t understand what this value means, you may end up inadvertently buying diamond stud earrings in the wrong size.

Because CTW is an abbreviation for “carat total weight,” it represents the combined carat weight of both diamond studs. So, if a pair of studs has a CTW of 1, that doesn’t mean each earring is made with a 1-carat diamond. On the contrary, it means the diamonds on each stud earring are actually only a half-carat each. Bear this in mind when shopping so you won’t end up disappointed with your purchase.

At the same time, while carat weight refers to the mass of the diamond, it doesn’t always equate to its size. Two diamonds with the same carat weight can appear different in size due to differences in cut and shape. It helps to get guidance from an attentive professional. John Atencio’s knowledgeable experts can help you choose a pair of studs with the exact right diamond shape and size for your unique style and budget.

The Trend Toward Bigger

Whatever you’ve heard, there’s simply no doubt that size matters when it comes to diamond stud earrings. Larger diamonds glitter with eye-catching fire. They inspire interest and attract attention while adding glamour and sophistication to any look.

These days, you’d have a hard time finding a modern fashionista who would prefer a smaller diamond over a larger, higher-carat stone. At the same time, lab-grown diamonds have also fueled the growing trend toward larger gemstones.

Created in dedicated facilities using highly advanced technology, these stunning stones are identical to natural diamonds both physically and optically. They also give people the ability to buy larger diamonds for the same price as smaller natural stones.

But while size is definitely important, it isn’t everything. Cut, clarity, and color are also important considerations for a truly stunning pair of diamond stud earrings.

Still, larger diamonds add a level of sophistication to any ensemble, making them the focal point of your look. Whether you’re aiming for understated elegance or a bold statement, larger studs can enhance your appearance and exude luxury that attracts attention.

large diamond stud earrings with yellow gold

Is Bigger Always Better?

Obviously, carat weight will have a major impact on the beauty and cost of your diamond studs. While beautiful, a 1-carat stone won’t command attention like a 2-carat diamond. When cut by a skilled jeweler, larger diamonds dazzle the eye and elevate any ensemble.

That said, when you select a larger gemstone, you want to make sure it has good clarity and color since blemishes will usually be more visible. This is because larger diamonds have bigger surface tables that are much more visible to the naked eye.

The 4 Cs of diamond quality—cut, color, clarity, and carat weight—all work to determine clarity, beauty, and value in any diamond.

Cut

This describes the polish, finish and proportion of the diamond. A highly skilled cutter uses precise artistry to fashion a gemstone, so it delivers optimal visual effects, including brightness (external and internal reflected light), fire (the scattering of white light), and scintillation (the gemstones sparkle and the pattern of dark and light areas produced by countless reflections within the stone).

Clarity

This refers to the clearness and purity of a diamond. Grades are assigned to every stone, with "I" describing diamonds with tiny inclusions and "F" describing diamonds with flawless clarity. Most diamond gemstones will have various grades that range from I to F. Inclusions are more visible in larger diamonds with broader surface tables.

Color

From yellow to white, diamonds receive a grade for how much color they contain. Diamonds graded in the J, K, and L range generally offer the best value for a customer’s dollar. Diamond buyers generally prefer colorless to near-colorless diamond gemstones.

Many buyers focus heavily on carat when considering diamond stud earrings, and it’s easy to see why. At the same time, cut, clarity, and diamond color combine to determine the overall beauty of any gemstone. When selecting diamond studs, it’s important to consider the overall quality to ensure that the larger size enhances the brilliance and beauty of the stone rather than highlighting any potential imperfections.

closeup of a woman's earlobe showcasing a diamond stud earring

Selecting Diamond Studs for Every Occasion

When choosing diamond studs, consider the occasion. For everyday wear, smaller carat weights might provide the perfect balance of subtle elegance and practicality. For formal events, larger studs can offer that extra touch of glamour and make a bold statement. Pairing your diamond studs with complementary pieces from John Atencio’s collection, such as a delicate diamond pendant or a bracelet, can create a coordinated, luxurious look suitable for any event.

Budget Considerations: Lab vs. Natural Diamonds

Choosing the right carat weight often comes down to budget considerations. Lab-grown diamonds offer an excellent alternative for those who want larger diamonds at a more affordable price. Since lab-grown diamonds are identical to natural diamonds in both appearance and structure, they provide a great option for buyers who prioritize size and beauty without compromising quality. Understanding the difference between lab and natural diamonds can help you find the perfect balance between size, quality, and cost.

The Importance of Diamond Certification

Certification is key to ensuring authenticity and quality when purchasing diamond studs. John Atencio offers only certified diamonds from reputable gemological laboratories like the GIA (Gemological Institute of America). A certified diamond guarantees that the gemstone has been evaluated by experts and meets the highest standards of cut, color, clarity, and carat weight. This level of assurance provides peace of mind for buyers and reinforces John Atencio’s commitment to high quality.

Unique John Atencio Diamond Studs

a product image of a pair of diamond stud earrings by John Atencio

 

John Atencio offers a wide range of expertly crafted diamond studs, each designed with precision and artistry. One standout collection is the U-turn diamond studs, which feature a sleek, modern design that adds a contemporary twist to classic diamond jewelry.

These pieces, along with other exclusive designs, reflect John’s dedication to creating luxurious, timeless jewelry that compliments any style. And when you pair them with one of John’s beautifully crafted diamond pendants, women's bracelets, or designer rings, it results in a stunning artistic expression of luxury and beauty unlike anything else.

Gifting Diamond Studs

Diamond studs are a perfect gift for special occasions like birthdays, anniversaries, and major milestones. Their timeless appeal makes them a thoughtful and luxurious way to express love. For a truly special gift, consider pairing diamond studs with a matching necklace or bracelet from John Atencio’s collection to create a complete set that will be cherished for years to come.

Shop online or visit one of John’s locations, in Denver, Fort Collins, Boulder or surrounding areas, where his attentive staff can help you find the perfect earrings and accessories for your distinctive jewelry collection.